The Graveyard

We started Buffalo Eats in February of 2009 and since then, we’ve written about thousands of restaurants. It’s only natural that some of those restaurants have closed since. We are going to keep track of those restaurants that are no longer with us with The Graveyard. Lets either fondly remember those shuttered restaurants or look back and laugh about how ridiculous they were (looking at you Dog e’ Style).

Anyways, here’s the list in alphabetical order.

Updated: 8/4/17

  • The 2nd Cup (Post 4/2009, Closed 2013)
  • 5 de Mayo Mexican Restaurant (Post 8/2009, Closed)
  • Abbott’s Frozen Custard (Post 4/2010, Closed)
  • Ambrosia (Post 10/2009, Closed)
  • Antoinette’s On The Hill (Post 2/2009 and 7/2009, Closed)
  • The Aud Sports Bar & Grill (Post 1/2010, Closed)
  • B. Ferrante’s Specialty Italian Cookies and Pastry (Post 10/2012, Closed)
  • Bambino Kitchen and Bar (Post 7/2011 and 6/2013, Closed 2015)
  • Betty Crockski (Post 6/2014, Closed 2015)
  • Bingo’s Dim Sum House (Post 12/2010, Closed)
  • Bistro Europa (Post 4/2009 and 3/2014, Closed 2014)
  • The Black Market Food Truck (Post 1/2013, Closed 2017)
  • Black Rock Kitchen and Bar (Post 9/2011 and 11/2013, Closed 2015)
  • Blue Monk (Post 11/2010 and 12/2012, Closed 2016)
  • Bourbon and Butter (Post 9/2014, Closed 2016)
  • Bozanna’s Pizzeria (Post, Closed)
  • Brother’s Restaurant & Pub (Post 6/2012, Closed)
  • Buffalo Street Grill (
  • Butterwood Sweet and Savory (Post 10/2012, Closed 2016)
  • Campieri’s Gourmet Pizza (Post, Closed)
  • Captain Jack’s Fish N Chips (Post 3/2010, Closed)
  • Century Grill
  • Chappie’s Northtown Pizza (Post 5/2012, Closed)
  • Charlie O’Briens (Post, Closed )
  • Chinese Dumpling House (Post 10/2015, Closed 2017)
  • Chow Chocolat (Post, Closed)
  • Cozumel Grill & Tequilla Bar (Post 11/2009, Closed)
  • Crust Pizza Bar (Post 11/2013, Closed 2014)
  • Cuchifrito Hut (Post 4/2011, Closed)
  • The Cupcake Orchard (Post 10/2011, Closed 2013)
  • Delish! (Post 2/2009, Closed 2011)
  • Delish Cooking and Pastry Shop (Post 9/2011, Closed 2014)
  • Dog e’ Style (Post 10/2014, Closed 2015)
  • Dug’s Dive (Post 6/2011, Closed)
  • East End Grill and Taproom (Post 7/2009, Closed)
  • Eddie’s Chophouse (Post 7/2015, Closed )
  • The Eights Bistro (Post 8/2011, Closed)
  • The Elmwood Lounge (Post 5/2010, Closed)
  • Empire Grill (Post 10/2011, Closed)
  • Falafel Bar (Post, Closed)
  • Fear’s Subs (Post 10/2010, Closed )
  • FiddleHeads (Post, Closed)
  • Firefly Cupcakes (Post 5/2012, Closed)
  • Flappy’s Pub (Post 2/2009, Closed)
  • Grumpy’s (Post 5/2011, Closed)
  • Harry’s Harbour Place Grille (Post 3/2011, Closed)
  • Hero Certified Burgers (Post 10/2015, Closed 2016)
  • Jacobi’s Pizza Express (Post 7/2011, Closed)
  • Jaguar at the Bistro (Post 3/2015, Closed 2016)
  • JD’s Smokin’ Grill and Bar (Post 4/2014, Closed 2015)
  • JP Bullfeathers
  • Jojo Bistro and Wine Bar (Post 10/2011, Closed)
  • Juniper (Post 2/2010, Closed)
  • K Cafe (Post 3/2015, Closed 2017)
  • The King and I (Post 1/2010, Closed)
  • King’s Court (Post 11/2009, Closed)
  • Knight Slider (Post 9/2012, Closed 2016)
  • Kung Food (Post 3/212, Closed)
  • Lagniappes French Quarter Cafe (Post 9/2009, Closed)
  • Laughlin’s (Post, Closed)
  • Le Metro (Post 12/2011, Closed 2012)
  • The Lodge (Posts 2/2014 and 3/2016, Closed 2017)
  • Madonna’s Ristorante (Post 11/2012, Closed )
  • Mango’z Jamaican Restaurant (Post 11/2011, Closed)
  • Manhattan’s Pizza and Pasta (Post 6/2014, Closed)
  • Mike A’s at the Hotel Lafayette (Post 6/2012, Closed 2014)
  • Morning Glory Cafe (Post 4/2011, Closed)
  • My Burger Bar (Post 2/2013, Closed 2016)
  • Nelson’s Ridge (Post 2/2012, Closed)
  • NoNoo Ramen (Post 1/2012, Closed 2013)
  • O’Briens Meats and Smokehouse (Post 4/2012, Closed)
  • O’Connell’s American Bistro (Post 4/2012, Closed)
  • Oshun (Post 8/2014, Closed 2017)
  • Papi’s Family Restaurant (Post 2/2011, Closed)
  • Pizza Junction (Post 5/2011, Closed)
  • Prime 490 (Post, Closed)
  • Quaker Bonnet Eatery (Post 1/2011, Closed)
  • Queen City Shaken & Stirred (Post 7/2014, Closed)
  • Rascal’s on Niagara (Post 9/2013, Closed 2015)
  • Redlinski’s Red Hots (Post 8/2012, Closed)
  • Reuben’s NY Deli (Post 9/2014, Closed 2015)
  • Rocky’s Indian Restaurant (Post 8/2012, Closed 2014)
  • Sample Restaurant
  • Serene Gardens (Post 1/2013, Closed 2014)
  • Scarlet (Post 4/2011, Closed)
  • Shadow Lounge (Post 4/2009, Closed)
  • Steak and Sub (Post, Closed)
  • Steelhead Irish Pub & Restaurant (
  • Sweet Tooth (Post 11/2010, Closed)
  • Swirls Cupcakery (Post 1/2012, Closed)
  • Tabree (Post 7/2013, Closed 2016)
  • Tandoori’s Royal Cuisine (Post 5/2011, Closed)
  • Tantalus Restaurant Bar & Cafe (Post 2/2009 & 3/2009, Closed 2013)
  • Taste of Soul (Post 5/2011, Closed)
  • Tina’s Italian Kitchen (Post, Closed)
  • Torches (Post 6/2010, Closed)
  • Vincenzo’s Italian Ice (Post, Closed)
  • Wasabi’s (Post 6/2009, Closed)
  • The Wine Thief (Post 4/2010, Closed)
  • WJ Morrissey’s Irish Pub (Post 2/2009, Closed)
  • Zillycakes (Post, Closed)